Can God Die? The Immortal God Of The Bible And The Missionary Paradox Of The Cross

Can God die? The Bible calls God immortal, yet Christians sing that God died on the cross. We weigh the creeds, the scripture and the Qur’an’s answer.

Published

Updated

Reading time

15 min read

Share

Dark grey clouds with the light of the sun breaking through in a golden band.

Photo: Magda Ehlers / Pexels

Put a simple question to a Christian missionary and watch what happens: can God die? Most will answer at once that he cannot. God is eternal; he has no beginning and no end. Then ask the second question: did Jesus die on the cross? The answer, again at once, is yes. And the third: is Jesus God? Yes. The three answers cannot all be true, and the missionary who gives them has to choose which one to qualify.

This is not a trick. It is the oldest difficulty in Christian theology, argued over in councils, settled by anathemas, and still sung, unresolved, in the hymns of the churches. Charles Wesley put it into the mouth of every Methodist congregation: “Amazing love! how can it be, that Thou, my God, shouldst die for me?” and, a verse later, “’Tis mystery all! The Immortal dies!”1 A Muslim reading those lines is entitled to ask what kind of mystery is meant: one that goes beyond reason, or one that goes against it.

This article sets out what the Bible says about the life of God, what the churches say happened at Golgotha, how theologians have tried to hold the two together, and what the Qur’an says about the God who does not die. Bible quotations are from the King James Version; Qur’an translations are from Yusuf Ali.2

The living God of the Hebrew Bible

The Hebrew scriptures do not argue that God is immortal. They assume it, and they set it against everything that is not God. When Moses’ song gives God’s own words, they are words of life without end: “See now that I, even I, am he, and there is no god with me: I kill, and I make alive […] For I lift up my hand to heaven, and say, I live for ever.”3 The God who kills and makes alive is not himself subject to killing.

The Psalms make the contrast between Creator and creation turn on exactly this point. The heavens and the earth will wear out; God will not:

Of old hast thou laid the foundation of the earth: and the heavens are the work of thy hands. They shall perish, but thou shalt endure: yea, all of them shall wax old like a garment; as a vesture shalt thou change them, and they shall be changed: But thou art the same, and thy years shall have no end.

Psalm 102:25–27

Another psalm places God before all time: “Before the mountains were brought forth, or ever thou hadst formed the earth and the world, even from everlasting to everlasting, thou art God.”4 Jeremiah gives him the title that runs through the whole of the Old Testament: “the LORD is the true God, he is the living God, and an everlasting king.”5 Isaiah adds that this God does not tire: “the everlasting God, the LORD, the Creator of the ends of the earth, fainteth not, neither is weary.”6 And the psalmist adds that he does not even sleep: “he that keepeth Israel shall neither slumber nor sleep.”7

Two further statements close every door through which a mortal God might enter. God does not change: “For I am the LORD, I change not.”8 And God is not a man: “God is not a man, that he should lie; neither the son of man, that he should repent”; “for I am God, and not man; the Holy One in the midst of thee.”9 Death is the deepest change a living thing can undergo, and it is the mark of what it is to be a creature. A God who does not change and is not a man cannot pass through it.

The same Bible makes it plain that God is not confined in the way a body is confined. When Solomon dedicated the Temple, the greatest building Israel ever raised for God, he asked: “But will God indeed dwell on the earth? behold, the heaven and heaven of heavens cannot contain thee; how much less this house that I have builded?”10 If the heaven of heavens cannot contain God, a human body nailed to a cross outside Jerusalem cannot contain him either, and what happens to that body does not happen to him.

Habakkuk 1:12 and the scribes’ correction

One verse shows how seriously the Jewish scribes took the life of God. The prophet Habakkuk, appalled that God would use the Babylonians to punish Judah, cries out: “Art thou not from everlasting, O LORD my God, mine Holy One? we shall not die.”11 The sentence reads oddly: the prophet praises God’s eternity and then speaks of his people’s survival.

Rabbinic tradition explains why. Habakkuk 1:12 is one of the tiqqune soferim, the “corrections of the scribes”, a list of passages where, according to the rabbis, the wording was altered out of reverence for God. The Mekhilta, an early commentary on Exodus, and the Midrash Tanhuma both name this verse, and say that the prophet’s words were “thou diest not” and that the scribes changed them to “we shall not die”.12 Modern scholars debate whether the scribes really made each change or whether the list records how later readers understood difficult verses.13 For our purpose the answer does not matter. Either way, Jewish readers found even the sentence “thou diest not” too close to the unthinkable to leave on the page: they would not set the word “die” beside the name of God, even to deny it.

Christianity, born among those same readers, came to affirm what they would not even deny in writing. That is the measure of the change.

The New Testament agrees: God alone has immortality

The New Testament does not abandon the Old on this point. If anything it is more emphatic. The First Epistle to Timothy twice gives God the title “immortal”, and the second time it makes immortality something that belongs to God alone:

Now unto the King eternal, immortal, invisible, the only wise God, be honour and glory for ever and ever. Amen.

[…] the blessed and only Potentate, the King of kings, and Lord of lords; Who only hath immortality, dwelling in the light which no man can approach unto; whom no man hath seen, nor can see.

1 Timothy 1:17; 6:15–16

Paul, writing to Rome, describes idolatry as the exchange of the immortal for the mortal: the pagans “changed the glory of the uncorruptible God into an image made like to corruptible man”.14 The Greek word translated “uncorruptible”, aphthartos, is the word for what cannot decay or perish. Paul’s complaint against the idolaters is precisely that they took the imperishable God and pictured him as a perishable man.

The same contrast appears where the New Testament speaks of temptation. James says that “God cannot be tempted with evil”, while the Epistle to the Hebrews says that Jesus “was in all points tempted like as we are, yet without sin”.15 On the plain reading, one of them is the God who cannot be tempted, and the other is a man who was. Jesus himself, according to John, said that “God is a Spirit”, and after the resurrection, according to Luke, that “a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as ye see me have.”16

And yet the churches say that God died

Against all of this stands the preaching of the cross. Paul’s gospel is that “Christ died for our sins according to the scriptures”.17 Mark records the moment: “Jesus cried with a loud voice, and gave up the ghost.”18 So long as Christ is a man sent by God, there is nothing here that conflicts with the immortality of God. The conflict begins when Christ is declared to be God himself.

The early preachers did not shrink from the conclusion. Around the year 170, Melito, bishop of Sardis, preached a Passover sermon that has survived complete. Its climax is an accusation against Israel: “He who hung the earth is hanging; he who fixed the heavens has been fixed […] the Sovereign has been insulted; God has been murdered.”19 The words became a charter for centuries of Christian hostility to Jews, and they show where the doctrine leads when it is stated without qualification.

The New Testament itself carries a trace of the same struggle. In Acts, Paul tells the elders of Ephesus “to feed the church of God, which he hath purchased with his own blood.”20 The phrase “the blood of God” troubled the copyists, and the manuscripts divide between “the church of God” and “the church of the Lord”. Bruce Metzger, the leading textual critic of the twentieth century, set out the evidence and the doubts, including the possibility that the original meant “with the blood of his own”, that is, of his own Son.21 Bart Ehrman has shown how the scribes of the early centuries altered such passages in both directions, as the debates over Christ’s nature raged.22

The way out: “he died in his human nature”

Educated Christians do not usually defend Melito’s words. They answer that God did not die in his divine nature; Christ died in his human nature, and because the two natures belong to one person, what happened to the human nature can be said of God. This is the doctrine the Council of Chalcedon defined in 451: one and the same Christ, “recognized in two natures, without confusion, without change, without division, without separation”.23

Pope Leo, whose letter was read and acclaimed at the council, stated the rule that governs it: “each form does what is proper to it in communion with the other: the Word performing what belongs to the Word, and the flesh carrying out what belongs to the flesh.”24 Dying belongs to the flesh. So, on Leo’s rule, it was the flesh that died.

Yet the churches would not let the matter rest there, because a merely human death would not do what the doctrine of atonement needs it to do. Cyril of Alexandria, whose letters were also endorsed at the councils, pronounced a curse on anyone who denied that God’s Word died:

If anyone does not confess that the Word of God suffered in the flesh and was crucified in the flesh and tasted death in the flesh and became the first-born from the dead, although as God he is life and life-giving, let him be anathema.

Cyril of Alexandria, Twelfth Anathema against Nestorius (430)25

The Second Council of Constantinople, in 553, went further and required every Christian to confess that the one crucified in the flesh is “true God and the Lord of glory and one of the members of the holy Trinity”.26 Notice the clause Cyril could not avoid: “although as God he is life and life-giving.” The most determined defender of the phrase “God died” had to concede in the same breath that God, as God, does not die.

A dilemma the creeds cannot escape

The missionary who wants to say that God died on the cross is therefore caught between two answers, and each costs him something he cannot afford.

The first answer: the divine nature died. If that is what is meant, then the Bible’s God is not immortal, and every verse cited above is false. The early church itself condemned this answer. When Praxeas and Noetus taught that the Father himself suffered on the cross, a view later called patripassianism, the church fathers rejected it, and Tertullian summed up Praxeas’ work in one bitter line: “he put to flight the Paraclete, and he crucified the Father.”27 But the Son, in the doctrine of the Trinity, is as fully God as the Father. If it is blasphemy to say the Father died, on what ground can it be orthodoxy to say that God the Son died? And if God died, who kept the universe in being for three days? The New Testament says of Christ that “by him all things consist” and that he is “upholding all things by the word of his power.”28 A dead God upholds nothing.

The second answer: only the human nature died. This is the answer of Leo and of most theologians since. It keeps the immortality of God, but at a price. If only the human nature died, then what died on the cross was a man. The phrase “God died” becomes a way of speaking, a rule of grammar the theologians call the communication of properties, and not a description of what happened.

That price is fatal to the doctrine of atonement. The classical argument for the atonement, as Anselm of Canterbury set it out in the eleventh century, depends on the death being the death of God. Man owes the satisfaction, he argued, but only God can pay it, so “it is necessary that one who is God and man should make it”.29 The worth of the sacrifice is infinite only because the one who dies is infinite. Take away the death of God, and you are left with the death of a righteous man: a noble death, but one of many in the history of the prophets, and one that could not, on Anselm’s own reckoning, pay an infinite debt.

So the missionary must choose. Either God died, against the Bible and against the fathers, or God did not die, and the cross is the death of a man, whose death no theology can turn into the payment of an infinite debt.

There is a third difficulty, which neither answer resolves. According to Mark, the last words of Jesus before his death were a cry: “Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani? which is, being interpreted, My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?”30 If Jesus is God, the cry is addressed by God to God, and God forsakes God. If Jesus is a servant of God crying to his Lord, as the Psalm he quotes was first prayed by a servant of God, the words make perfect sense.

Is “death” the end of life, or the parting of soul and body?

Some apologists answer that death does not mean annihilation. It is the parting of the soul from the body. When Jesus died, his human soul left his human body, but nothing happened to his divinity, so the immortality of God is untouched.

The answer is true as far as it goes, and it is the second answer above in other words. If death is the separation of a human soul from a human body, then God, who is neither a human soul nor a human body, did not die. The death was entirely human. Nothing in this answer rescues the claim that the infinite God paid the price of sin by dying. It only describes, more precisely, what kind of death occurred: the death of a man.

The Qur’an also speaks of death as the taking of the soul. “It is Allah that takes the souls (of men) at death; and those that die not (He takes) during their sleep: those on whom He has passed the decree of death, He keeps back (from returning to life), but the rest He sends (to their bodies) for a term appointed.”31 The one who takes the souls is God; the souls taken are creatures’. No verse anywhere suggests that God’s own soul could be taken, because God is not a creature with a soul to lose.

What the Qur’an says about the God who does not die

The Qur’an gives God a name the Bible gives him too, but it gives it far more often: al-Hayy, the Living. The greatest verse in the Qur’an, the Throne Verse, begins with it: “Allah! There is no god but He,-the Living, the Self-subsisting, Eternal. No slumber can seize Him nor sleep.”32 The psalmist said that God neither slumbers nor sleeps; the Qur’an says the same, in nearly the same words.

It then draws the conclusion the Bible leaves implicit, in a verse that answers the question of this article directly: “And put thy trust in Him Who lives and dies not; and celebrate his praise; and enough is He to be acquainted with the faults of His servants.”33 Trust is owed to the one who cannot die, because only he will still be there when every other object of trust has gone. Everything else will pass: “All that is on earth will perish: But will abide (for ever) the Face of thy Lord,- full of Majesty, Bounty and Honour.”34

The Qur’an also turns the question round. If Jesus could be destroyed, he is not God:

In blasphemy indeed are those that say that Allah is Christ the son of Mary. Say: “Who then hath the least power against Allah, if His will were to destroy Christ the son of Mary, his mother, and all every – one that is on the earth?”

Qur’an 5:17

And it gives the sign of his creatureliness that any reader of the Gospels can confirm: “Christ the son of Mary was no more than a messenger; many were the messengers that passed away before him. His mother was a woman of truth. They had both to eat their (daily) food.”35 A being who must eat to live is a being who can die, and a being who can die is not the Living who dies not.

The Qur’an’s account of the end of Jesus’ life on earth is itself shaped by this. It denies that his enemies killed him at all: “they killed him not, nor crucified him, but so it was made to appear to them […] Nay, Allah raised him up unto Himself; and Allah is Exalted in Power, Wise.”36 On the Islamic view, then, the question “can God die?” never arises at the cross. Jesus is a prophet; God saved him; and God himself is beyond the reach of death, as he is beyond the reach of slumber.

Can God die? Questions for the missionary

When the subject comes up in conversation, a Muslim can put the matter in a few plain questions, and let the Christian answer them from his own Bible:

  • If God “only hath immortality” (1 Timothy 6:16), did Jesus have immortality on the cross? If he did, he did not die. If he did not, was he God?
  • If it is heresy to say that the Father died on the cross, why is it orthodoxy to say that God the Son died, when the Son is equally God?
  • If only the human nature of Christ died, was the sacrifice the death of a man? And how can the death of a man pay an infinite debt?
  • Who upheld “all things by the word of his power” while the one who upholds them lay dead in the tomb?
  • When Jesus cried “My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?”, who forsook whom?

None of these questions is new. Christian theologians have asked every one of them, and the answers they gave filled libraries and divided churches. A creed that needs a library to explain how the immortal God died is a creed that has asked reason to accept what reason refuses. Wesley called it “mystery all”. The Qur’an calls it something simpler: a claim about God that God never made.

Conclusion

The Bible’s own witness is that God is “from everlasting to everlasting”, that his years “shall have no end”, that he “fainteth not, neither is weary”, and that he alone “hath immortality”. The Jewish scribes would not write the word “die” beside his name, even to deny it. The Christian creeds, having made a man into God, had to find a way to make God die, and found only two: to make the immortal mortal, which the Bible forbids, or to say that God died while meaning that a man did, which empties the atonement of the very thing it needs.

The Qur’an’s answer keeps what the prophets taught. God is the Living who does not die; Jesus is his honoured messenger, whom God raised up to himself; and the trust of the believer belongs to the One who will remain when everything on earth has passed away. Readers who want to take the argument further will find our studies of the divinity of Jesus and the crucifixion as an atonement a useful next step, and our commentary on Surah al-Ikhlas sets out, in four verses, the God whom the question “can God die?” was never meant to touch.

And Allah knows best.

  1. Charles Wesley, “And Can It Be That I Should Gain” (1738), stanzas 1 and 2, first published under the title “Free Grace” in John and Charles Wesley, Hymns and Sacred Poems (London, 1739). ↩︎
  2. Bible quotations are from the Authorised (King James) Version of 1611, in its standard modern spelling. Translations of the Qur’an are from A. Yusuf Ali, The Holy Qur’an: Text, Translation and Commentary (Lahore, 1934–1937), occasionally shortened. ↩︎
  3. Deuteronomy 32:39–40. ↩︎
  4. Psalm 90:2. ↩︎
  5. Jeremiah 10:10. ↩︎
  6. Isaiah 40:28. ↩︎
  7. Psalm 121:4. ↩︎
  8. Malachi 3:6. ↩︎
  9. Numbers 23:19; Hosea 11:9. ↩︎
  10. 1 Kings 8:27; the prayer is repeated in 2 Chronicles 6:18. ↩︎
  11. Habakkuk 1:12. ↩︎
  12. Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael, Shirata 6, on Exodus 15:7; Midrash Tanhuma, Beshallah 16. The list and its history are studied in Carmel McCarthy, The Tiqqune Sopherim and Other Theological Corrections in the Masoretic Text of the Old Testament, Orbis Biblicus et Orientalis 36 (Freiburg: Universitätsverlag; Göttingen: Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht, 1981). ↩︎
  13. McCarthy concludes that only some of the passages on the traditional lists show a genuine scribal alteration; others are later exegetical claims. Either way the tradition shows what Jewish readers found unfit to say of God. ↩︎
  14. Romans 1:23. ↩︎
  15. James 1:13; Hebrews 4:15. ↩︎
  16. John 4:24; Luke 24:39. ↩︎
  17. 1 Corinthians 15:3. ↩︎
  18. Mark 15:37. ↩︎
  19. Melito of Sardis, On Pascha 96, in Stuart George Hall, ed. and trans., Melito of Sardis: On Pascha and Fragments, Oxford Early Christian Texts (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1979), section 96. ↩︎
  20. Acts 20:28. ↩︎
  21. Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, 2nd ed. (Stuttgart: Deutsche Bibelgesellschaft; New York: United Bible Societies, 1994), on Acts 20:28. ↩︎
  22. Bart D. Ehrman, The Orthodox Corruption of Scripture: The Effect of Early Christological Controversies on the Text of the New Testament (New York: Oxford University Press, 1993). ↩︎
  23. The Definition of the Council of Chalcedon (451), in Norman P. Tanner, ed., Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils, vol. 1 (London: Sheed & Ward; Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press, 1990), Council of Chalcedon, Definition of the Faith. ↩︎
  24. Leo I, Letter 28 (the “Tome” to Flavian, 449), chapter 4; Tanner, Decrees, vol. 1, prints it with the acts of Chalcedon. ↩︎
  25. Cyril of Alexandria, Third Letter to Nestorius (430), with its twelve anathemas, in Tanner, Decrees, vol. 1, among the documents of the Council of Ephesus (431). ↩︎
  26. Second Council of Constantinople (553), Anathema 10, in Tanner, Decrees, vol. 1. The formula “one of the Trinity suffered in the flesh”, championed by the Scythian monks in the 520s, is known as the theopaschite formula. ↩︎
  27. Tertullian, Against Praxeas 1, in Ante-Nicene Fathers, ed. Alexander Roberts and James Donaldson, vol. 3 (Buffalo: Christian Literature Publishing, 1885). ↩︎
  28. Colossians 1:17; Hebrews 1:3. ↩︎
  29. Anselm of Canterbury, Cur Deus Homo (Why God Became Man, 1098), book 2, chapter 6; compare 2.14 on the infinite worth of that death, in Brian Davies and G. R. Evans, eds., Anselm of Canterbury: The Major Works (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1998). ↩︎
  30. Mark 15:34, quoting Psalm 22:1. ↩︎
  31. Qur’an 39:42; compare 6:60. ↩︎
  32. Qur’an 2:255; the same opening is in 3:2, and compare 40:65, “He is the Living (One): there is no god but He”. ↩︎
  33. Qur’an 25:58. ↩︎
  34. Qur’an 55:26–27; compare 28:88, “Everything (that exists) will perish except His own Face.” ↩︎
  35. Qur’an 5:75. The Gospels record Jesus eating before and after the resurrection: for example Luke 7:34 and 24:41–43. ↩︎
  36. Qur’an 4:157–158; compare 3:55. ↩︎

Next in Christian Doctrinesal Faruqi on Christian Ethics: The Ethic of Jesus Against Peccatism and Saviourism10 min readBlack-and-white portrait of Isma'il Raji al Faruqi in a dark suit, looking at the camera.

Discussion

0 comments

Before you comment

Keep to the argument of the article and cite your sources where you can. Comments that contain links wait for approval, and abusive comments are not published.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.