Book Reviews

Response indexes

Reviews of the books most often cited against Islam, and of the scholarship that answers them.

21 responses

Book Reviews

  1. Ali Sina’s “Understanding Muhammad: A Psychobiography”

    For those who are familiar with “Faithfreedom International”, the name of its founder Ali Sina (a pseudonym) is synonymous with the bigotry and vile rhetoric often displayed against…

    Mohd Elfie Nieshaem Juferi · 7 min read

  2. A Jewel It’s Not: Review of “The Jewel of Medina: A Novel” by Sherry Jones

    After Denise Spellberg, associate professor of history and Middle Eastern studies at the University of Texas, assessed the manuscript as “a very ugly, stupid, piece of work” which…

    Glenn C. Altschuler · 4 min read

  3. Hagarism: The Story Of A Book Written By Infidels For Infidels

    Scholarly decency demands that the authors of the 1977 book Hagarism: The Making of the Islamic World officially repudiate a scandalous thesis, one in which they no longer…

    Liaquat Ali Khan · 4 min read

  4. In the Fog of History: Review of G. R. Hawting, “The Idea of Idolatry and the Emergence of Islam. From Polemic to History”

    The issue raised by this monograph thus can only exist, as a historical issue, if there is a marked difference between the Qur'an and what the author parenthetically…

    Walid A. Saleh · 12 min read

  5. Book Review Of “The Sword of the Prophet” By Serge Trifkovic

    The book The Sword of the Prophet written by Dr. Serge (a.k.a. Srdja) Trifkovic of Serbian extract, is similar to many such post-Cold War era books (written by…

    Habib Siddiqui · 14 min read

  6. Jimmy Carter, “Palestine Peace Not Apartheid”

    Following his #1 New York Times bestseller, Our Endangered Values, the former President, winner of the Nobel Peace Prize, offers an assessment of what must be done to…

    Israeli Watch · 8 min read

  7. Tarif Khalidi, “The Muslim Jesus”

    The following is a synopsis of Tarif Khalidi's book entitled: "The Muslim Jesus", which might lead people to learn more about Islam. Tarif Khalidi is Sir Thomas Adams'…

    Bismika Allahuma Team · 7 min read

  8. The Destiny Of Israel: Review Of “Jerusalem in the Qur’an”

    We must realize that something horrible is in store for the world in which starving half a million children to death is a valid price but calling Israel…

    Abid Ullah Jan · 14 min read

  9. Book Review of Bart Ehrman’s “Misquoting Jesus: The Story Behind Who Changed the Bible and Why”

    The book "Misquoting Jesus: The Story Behind Who Changed The Bible and Why" from Prof. Bart Ehrman can be described as an introduction to New Testament textual criticism…

    The Reviewer · 5 min read

  10. Ibn Warraq’s “Origins Of The Koran”: A Critical Analysis

    This book, edited by the rather nebulous personage of "Ibn Warraq" (neither his full name nor his institutional affiliation, if any, are anywhere given), consists of thirteen previously…

    Yasin Dutton · 7 min read

  11. Review Of “The Collection of the Qur’an” By John Burton

    The last work that shall be discussed is a relatively recent one: The Collection of the Qur'an by John Burton. It was published in 1977 by Cambridge University…

    Abu Ammar Yasir Qadhi · 7 min read

  12. “Geschichte des Qorans” Of Theodore Noeldeke

    The first work is by Theodore Noeldeke, a very famous German Orientalist. He entitled it Geschichte des Qorans, or "History of the Qur'an". The work was written with…

    Abu Ammar Yasir Qadhi · 3 min read

  13. Simon Hopkins, Review of “Christoph Luxenberg”, Die syro-aramaiche Lesart des Koran… [i.e., "The Syro-Aramaic Reading of the Qur’an..]

    It reinforces the claim I have been making for ages that the real problem is not in Luxenberg's interpretation of this or that term, so that a clever…

    Asif Iqbal · 1 min read

  14. Review of Ibn Warraq (ed.), "The Origins of the Koran: Classic Essays on Islam's Holy Book", Prometheus Books, NY: 1998

    Journal of American Oriental Society (JAOS), Volume 122, Number 3, (July-Sept 2002), p. 658 This is a collection of articles in Qur’?nic studies by some of the most…

    Todd Lawson · 5 min read

  15. A Review of Geraldine Brooks' "Nine Parts of Desire: The Hidden World of Islamic Women"

    “CyberMuslima” (Pseudonym) I intended this to be a short essay piece, a review of sorts pointing out the most grievous sections of this book. However, as I read…

    · 19 min read

  16. Ali Dashti’s “23 Years: A Study of the Prophetic Career of Muhammad”: A Review

    Since this book has come up as a topic, and I have read it, I thought, insha’allah, I’d write my impressions. I ordered the book sight unseen because…

    Jeremiah McAuliffe · 10 min read

  17. Review of "Christoph Luxenberg", Die syro-aramäische Lesart des Koran: Ein Beitrag zur Entschlüsselung der Koransprache

    [i.e., “The Syro-Aramaic Reading of the Qur’?n: A Contribution tothe Decipherment of the Qur’?nic Language] François de Blois Appeared in Journal of Qur’anic Studies, Vol. V, Issue 1,…

    · 12 min read

  18. Scholarship or Sophistry? Bernard Lewis and the New Orientalism

    It would appear from the fulsome praise heaped by mainstream reviewers on Bernard Lewis’s most recent and well-timed book, What Went Wrong? Western Impact and Middle Eastern Response…

    M. Shahid Alam · 32 min read

  19. A Devil Theory of Islam

    Source A Review of Judith Miller’s “God Has Ninety-Nine Names: Reporting From a Militant Middle East” The Nation, August 12/19, 1996 God Has Ninety-Nine Names Judith Miller is…

    Edward W. Said · 12 min read

  20. Criticism of Arthur Jeffery’s “Materials For The History Of The Text Of The Qur’an: The Old Codices”

    This excerpt criticises the work of the Orientalist Arthur Jeffery mentioned as well as discusses the various misunderstandings of the technical terms held by Jeffery.

    Abu Ammaar Yasir Qadhi · 7 min read

  21. Book Review of Ibn Warraq's "The Quest for the Historical Muhammad", NY: 2000

    The Quest for the Historical Muhammad Middle East Studies Association Bulletin, Volume 35, Number 1, Summer 2001, Cambridge University Press, ISSN 0026-3184, p. 75 The study of Islam’s…

    Fred M. Donner · 3 min read