Replies to Answering Islam and Jochen Katz

Response indexes

Every response on this site to the writing and claims of Answering Islam and Jochen Katz, gathered in one place.

11 responses

The Qur'an

  1. Surah al-Anbiyaa:30 and the Missionary Felix Culpa

    Recently the world's most maladroit missionaries have allowed an impromptu piece to be published in response to Shabbir Ally's views on Surah al-Anbiyaa: 30. Personally I do believe…

    Servidor Hernandez Ibn Musa · 13 min read

  2. Is The Qur’an Really The Work of Multiple Hands?

    We were recently confronted with the claims of Denis Giron in his article that the composition of the Qur’an is simply the work of multiple authors. In this…

    Mohd Elfie Nieshaem Juferi · 21 min read

  3. Waraqa ibn Naufal and the Christian Polemics

    In an article of his, Jochen Katz has made much of the narratives about Waraqa ibn Naufal, and has conjectured on his alleged influence on Prophet Muhammad’s(P) religious…

    Asif Iqbal · 3 min read

  4. When the Evangelist Becomes a Shaikh, the Angels Become Worshippers of Adam

    When the Evangelist becomes a Shaikh, the angels become polytheists, worshipping Adam instead of Allah. When the Evangelist becomes a Shaikh, the Nasikh becomes Mansukh, the Mutlaq becomes…

    Jalal Abualrub · 51 min read

Op-Ed

  1. The Küng Controversy: An Analysis of Jochen Katz’s Recent Tirade

    Some time ago, MENJ published Hans Kung's view of the Prophet Muhammad(P) along with a brief editor's note. It seems that Jochen Katz was quite outraged at this…

    Aragorn of Arathorn · 7 min read

  2. Splitting Hairs, The “Jochen Katz” Way

    Answering Islam has posted an early reaction in objection to our publishing of Han Kung on the Prophet Muhammad (P). There are several issues in this reaction by…

    Mohd Elfie Nieshaem Juferi · 3 min read

  3. Some Notes On Sam Shamoun’s Lowly Character

    Recently I came across email exchanges that took place between Jalal Abualrab and the Christian missionary Sam Shamoun. I have heard that the missionary Shamoun is a very…

    Aragorn of Arathorn · 37 min read

Polemical Rebuttals

  1. Answering Islam: Preaching What They Do Not Practise?

    In one of their pages, Answering Islam had made the following claim with the clear intention of "poisoning the well" where Muslim sites are concerned. The rest of…

    Mohd Elfie Nieshaem Juferi · 4 min read

  2. Wood Chopped Down: The Information Superhighway and the Nonsense of Christian Missionary Belligerence

    From the beginning of Orientalism, the Christian missionaries have been assuming that Islam is "headless" enough to be attacked and scrutinised with a ferocity that one can only…

    Mohd Elfie Nieshaem Juferi · 7 min read

Christianity

  1. One Hundred Christian Proofs Of Islamic Falsehood

    1) ARGUMENT FROM DISAGREEMENT I believe that the Bible is the word of God. The Qur’an disagrees with the Bible. Therefore, Islam is false. 2) ARGUMENT FROM ACTIONS…

    Demijan Omeragic · 20 min read

The Bible

  1. Observation of Answering Islam’s Response to “I AM WHAT I AM: A Bible Commentary”

    The missionary Sam Shamoun under the banner of the infamous missionary website, Answering Islam, have claimed in his series of articles [1][2][3][4] that he has “refuted” our analysis…

    Tera Tak Adamar and Mohd Elfie Nieshaem Juferi · 5 min read