The question is simple: is there a hierarchy within the Trinity? Christian apologists who answer it often reach for the most popular illustration in lay Christian apologetics.
Water, the illustration runs, exists as ice, as liquid and as vapour. A creature on Pluto, where everything is frozen, would insist that water is only ice. Muslims, the apologist suggests, are like that creature: they cannot imagine one God existing in three persons, because they have only ever seen Him one way.
The illustration is attractive and it is wrong, on two counts. It describes a doctrine the historic creeds condemned, and it cannot accommodate the one Person of the Trinity who became a man.
This article aims to provide context to that analogy and to the question of rank it was meant to answer, insha’Allah. We take the analogy first, then the Gospel evidence for a hierarchy, and then the creed that forbids one.
What the analogy describes
Ice, liquid water and vapour are three states of one substance. A given quantity of water exists in one state at a time, and it passes from one state to another as its temperature changes.
Apply that to God and the result is a single divine being who appears as the Father, then as the Son, then as the Spirit, depending on circumstance. The early Church called that teaching modalism, and it condemned Sabellius for holding it.
The orthodox doctrine requires something else entirely: three Persons who exist simultaneously and eternally, each fully God, none of them a phase of the others. The water analogy cannot represent simultaneity, because ice that has melted is no longer ice.
The usual defence is that no analogy is complete. That is true of every analogy. It does not rescue one whose central feature reproduces a condemned heresy.
The member of a different nature
The second flaw concerns nature. Whatever state water takes, its nature stays the same. Ice is H2O, water is H2O and vapour is H2O.
Christian doctrine holds that the Father is spirit and the Holy Spirit is spirit. The Son, however, took on a complete human nature in the incarnation, and Christians hold that he retains it to this day.
So the analogy breaks at exactly the point it needed to hold. One member of the Christian Trinity has a nature the other two lack.
One common Christian answer concedes the point. The Word, on this answer, “no longer possessed the ATTRIBUTES of spirit; but now possessed the attributes of a physical man.”
As a man, the Word hungered, thirsted, tired and slept. As a man, he was “limited in power” and “limited in knowledge”.
We accept that description of the Jesus of the Gospels. A being who is limited in power and limited in knowledge is the creature the Qur’an describes. He is a servant of God.
The Gospel evidence for rank
The question of hierarchy is settled by the New Testament more directly than by any analogy. Its writers repeatedly place the Son beneath the Father.
In the Gospel of John, Jesus tells his disciples: “my Father is greater than I.”1 In the same Gospel he addresses the Father in prayer as “the only true God”, and identifies himself as the one whom that God sent.2
In Mark, Jesus says of the day and hour of the end that no one knows it, “neither the Son, but the Father.”3 The Father knows what the Son does not.
Paul places the subordination at the end of history as well as in the earthly ministry. “The head of every man is Christ,” he writes, “and the head of Christ is God.”4 When all things are subdued to the Son, “then shall the Son also himself be subject unto him that put all things under him, that God may be all in all.”5
These texts describe rank. One sends and the other is sent; one knows the hour and the other confesses that he does not.
In Paul, one is subject and the other is the God to whom he is subject.
The creed that forbids rank
The Athanasian Creed, which many Western churches still recite, rules this hierarchy out. “In this Trinity none is afore, or after other,” it states, “none is greater, or less than another.”6
The creed and the Gospel of John cannot both be taken at face value. The Gospel has Jesus say that the Father is greater than he is; the creed says that no Person is greater than another.
Christian theologians have answered the tension in two ways. The older answer assigns every subordinate statement to the human nature of Christ. On that view, Jesus speaks as a man when he calls the Father greater, and as God when he claims equality.
A second answer, held by some Evangelical theologians, accepts an eternal subordination of the Son to the Father in role, while denying any inequality in being. Wayne Grudem presents this view in his widely used systematic theology.7 Other Evangelical scholars, among them Kevin Giles, reject it as a revival of the subordinationism the early Church condemned.8
So the Trinitarians themselves cannot agree whether their Godhead contains a hierarchy. That disagreement answers the question better than any Muslim could.
The analogy from the self
A second illustration is also common. A human being, it argues, is both body and mind, yet remains one person. Why should God not be three and one?
The analogy proves less than it claims. A human being has many faculties, thought, sight, memory and will among them, and none of them is a person.
A faculty never prays to another faculty, sends it on an errand or knows what it does not.
The Trinity as the Gospels present it involves exactly those relationships. The Son prays to the Father, the Father sends the Son, and the Son confesses ignorance of what the Father knows.
At the end of every such analysis there is still one human being. The creed, by contrast, requires three who each are God, and then insists that there are not three Gods.
Jesus and the first commandment
The Gospels record what Jesus himself named as the foundation of religion. A scribe asked him which commandment was first of all.
“The first of all the commandments is, Hear, O Israel; The Lord our God is one Lord,” Jesus answered, and he went on to the command to love God with all the heart, soul, mind and strength.9 The scribe agreed that there is one God, “and there is none other but he”. Jesus told him that he was not far from the kingdom of God.
The scene contains no Trinity. A Jewish teacher recites the creed of Israel, and a Jewish scribe affirms it, and the teacher commends him.
A second scene points the same way. A man addressed Jesus as “Good Master”. Jesus answered: “Why callest thou me good? there is none good but one, that is, God.”10
Christian commentators read the reply as a test of the man’s faith. Read as it stands, it places Jesus on the side of the creature and reserves goodness in its fullness for God.
The Muslim need not force either passage. Jesus recited the Shema, and the Qur’an summarises his message in the same terms: “Allah is my Lord and your Lord, so worship Him alone.”11
The Islamic alternative
The Qur’an addresses the doctrine directly and without analogy. “Say, ˹O Prophet,˺ ‘He is Allah, One ˹and Indivisible˺; Allah, the Sustainer ˹needed by all˺.
He has never had offspring, nor was He born. And there is none comparable to Him.’”12
It speaks to the Christians by name: “Do not say, ‘Trinity.’ Stop! ˹It is˺ better for you.”13 And it describes the Messiah as he described himself in John’s Gospel: a messenger sent by God.14
The Muslim position requires no illustration from chemistry. God is one, and He is unlike His creation. Jesus is a prophet who prayed to God, depended on God and confessed that God knew what he did not.
The Jews of Jesus’ own day recited the same truth in the Shema: “Hear, O Israel: The LORD our God is one LORD.”15 They understood “one” as one. The Church later read the word as three-in-one, and the Jews have never accepted the reading.
The verdict
The water analogy fails the doctrine it was meant to explain. It describes the modalism the creeds condemned, and it breaks on the incarnation, where one Person takes a nature the others do not share.
The hierarchy the question asked about is real in the Christian scriptures. The Father is greater, the Father knows the hour, and the Son will be subject to Him. The Athanasian Creed forbids that hierarchy, and Evangelical theologians still dispute it.
Muslims need none of these defences. We read the words of Jesus in John and Mark as he said them, and they describe a servant of the One God.
And only God knows best.
- John 14:28 (King James Version). ↩︎
- John 17:3. ↩︎
- Mark 13:32 (King James Version). ↩︎
- 1 Corinthians 11:3 (King James Version). ↩︎
- 1 Corinthians 15:28 (King James Version). ↩︎
- The Athanasian Creed (Quicunque vult), as printed in the Book of Common Prayer (1662). ↩︎
- Wayne Grudem, Systematic Theology: An Introduction to Biblical Doctrine (Inter-Varsity Press and Zondervan, 1994), ch. 14, esp. pp. 251–254. ↩︎
- Kevin Giles, The Trinity and Subordinationism: The Doctrine of God and the Contemporary Gender Debate (InterVarsity Press, 2002). ↩︎
- Mark 12:28–34 (King James Version). ↩︎
- Mark 10:17–18 (King James Version). ↩︎
- Qur’an 3:51, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. ↩︎
- Qur’an 112:1–4, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. ↩︎
- Qur’an 4:171, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. ↩︎
- Qur’an 5:75. ↩︎
- Deuteronomy 6:4 (King James Version). ↩︎




Leave a Reply