“A Glutton and a Drunkard”: Matthew 11:19, Deuteronomy 21 and the Humanity of Jesus

The Gospels record that Jesus was called a glutton and a drunkard. The charge was a slander with a legal edge, and the Gospels themselves preserve the humanity it accidentally confirms.

Published

Updated

Reading time

7 min read

The question sounds like a provocation: was Jesus a drunkard and a glutton? Christians who hear it from a Muslim are often offended. They assume the Muslim invented the charge to insult their Lord.

Muslims invented nothing. The words come from the Gospels.

“The Son of man came eating and drinking,” Jesus says in Matthew, “and they say, Behold a man gluttonous, and a winebibber, a friend of publicans and sinners.”1 Luke records the same saying.2

Christian responses to the question tend to argue about tone and leave the text alone.

This article aims to provide context to that saying, insha’Allah: where the charge came from, what it meant in the law of Moses, and why a Muslim reads it differently from both the accusers and the Christian apologists.

Our position stated plainly

Muslims hold that Jesus son of Mary, peace be upon him, was a prophet of God. We hold that he committed no sin and never drank what God had forbidden.

Our belief in his sinlessness belongs to a wider doctrine. Islam teaches ʿiṣmah (the divine protection of the prophets from grave sin), and we hold it of Adam, Abraham, Moses, Solomon and Muhammad, peace be upon them all, alongside Jesus.

So we reject the charge of gluttony and drunkenness. The interesting question is why the Gospels recorded it, and what it reveals.

Who made the accusation

The saying in Matthew is a complaint about the critics of two prophets. John the Baptist came fasting and abstaining, and his critics said he had a demon. Jesus came eating and drinking with ordinary people, and the same critics called him a glutton and a winebibber.

The point of the saying is that no conduct would satisfy them. The charge belongs to the opponents of Jesus, and the Gospel writer preserves it to expose them.

A Christian who asks a Muslim whether Jesus was a drunkard should therefore ask his own Gospel first. The Gospel records the accusation, and the accusers were the religious authorities of his own people.

John who fasted

The saying sets Jesus beside John the Baptist, and the Qur’an honours both. John, whom the Qur’an calls Yaḥyā, receives wisdom “while still a child”, along with purity and compassion. He was “devout, and kind to his parents”, and “peace be upon him the day he was born, and the day of his death, and the day he will be raised back to life”.3

Muslims therefore read the saying in Matthew as a defence of two prophets against the same critics. One abstained, the other ate with sinners, and the critics slandered both.

The phrase his critics chose deserves attention. “Glutton and drunkard” was a fixed pair in the law and wisdom of Israel.

The Book of Deuteronomy lays down the procedure for a son who will not obey his parents. They bring him to the elders of the city and declare: “This our son is stubborn and rebellious, he will not obey our voice; he is a glutton, and a drunkard.” The men of the city then stone him.4

The Book of Proverbs warns against keeping company with “winebibbers” and “riotous eaters of flesh”, because “the drunkard and the glutton shall come to poverty”.5

The pairing in Matthew echoes that formula. If the echo is deliberate, the critics of Jesus were reaching for more than mockery. They used the language of a capital charge.

That reading fits the rest of the Gospel narrative, in which the authorities seek a legal ground to destroy him. It also explains why the Gospel writers kept the insult. They were recording the case his enemies built against him.

The wedding at Cana and the Christian difficulty

Christian unease with the question has a reason that often goes unstated. The Gospels do present Jesus drinking wine and providing it.

At the wedding in Cana, the Gospel of John reports that Jesus turned water into wine when the hosts ran short, and that the steward praised the quality of the new wine above the old.6 At the last supper, the Synoptic Gospels have him take the cup and give thanks.7

Christians who drink in moderation draw on these passages, and most Christian traditions permit wine. We do not dispute their reading of their own scripture on that point.

We note only the tension it creates for the missionary who cites the Bible to show that Jesus was more righteous than Muhammad (P). The Prophet of Islam forbade intoxicants entirely.8 The Jesus of the Fourth Gospel supplied a wedding feast with wine after the guests had already drunk freely.

What eating and drinking proves

The saying in Matthew carries a second implication, and it matters more to a Muslim than the insult does. “The Son of man came eating and drinking.” The Gospel presents Jesus as a man who ate, drank and needed both.

The Qur’an makes exactly this observation in its argument about his nature. “The Messiah, son of Mary, was no more than a messenger,” it says, and “they both used to eat food.”9

The commentators explain the logic. A being who eats is dependent. He hungers, digests and passes what he has eaten, and a being with those needs cannot be the self-sufficient God who needs nothing.

The Gospels supply the evidence for the Qur’an’s argument. Jesus hungers in the wilderness after his fast.10

He hungers on the road to Jerusalem and looks for figs on a tree out of season.11 After the resurrection, according to Luke, he asks for food and eats broiled fish before his disciples.12

The Christian creeds hold that Jesus was fully man and fully God, and they answer this argument by assigning the eating to his human nature. A Muslim may ask a simpler question. Which nature hungered, and which nature was hungered for when he prayed to his Father?

The table spread from heaven

The Qur’an has its own scene of Jesus and food, and it frames the matter as a Muslim would. The fifth chapter takes its name from it: al-Māʾidah, the Table Spread.

The disciples ask Jesus whether his Lord can send down a table from heaven. Jesus warns them to fear God, and when they insist that they wish to eat from it and have their hearts reassured, he prays: “O Allah, our Lord! Send us from heaven a table spread with food as a feast for us.”13

The scene presents Jesus as the one who asks. He turns to his Lord for the food and calls Him “the best of providers”. God answers the prayer and warns that whoever disbelieves after it will face a punishment unlike any other.

Here the Qur’an and the Gospel saying meet. Jesus eats, and Jesus prays for food. In both scriptures the miracle of provision belongs to God, and the man who receives it is His servant.

The slander and the Muslim answer

A related charge often follows. The Christian apologist quotes the Qur’an, in which God tells the Prophet (P) that He has forgiven him his past and future faults, and argued that only Jesus was sinless.14

The verse addresses the Prophet’s standing before God, and the classical commentators read it as a declaration of honour after the treaty of Ḥudaybiyah. It records no specific sin, and it gives no support to the claim that Muhammad (P) lived in transgression.

The double standard in the objection is plain. The Christian reads the worst meaning into a Qur’anic verse about forgiveness. He then defends Jesus against a Gospel verse that records an explicit accusation of drunkenness.

A Muslim needs no double standard here. We defend Jesus against the accusation in Matthew, and we defend Muhammad (P) against the misreading of the Qur’an, on the same ground. Both were prophets of God, and both were protected from the sins their enemies alleged.

What Muslims owe Jesus

Christians sometimes ask whether Muslim writing on Jesus exists only to insult him. The question has the matter backwards.

Islam requires every Muslim to believe in Jesus as a prophet, to honour his mother as the best of women, and to reject every slander against them both. The Qur’an itself rebuts the slander that his own people brought against Mary.15

Our objections are to the doctrines Christians built around Jesus after him. The man himself we defend, and in this case we defend him against a charge that only the Gospels preserve.

The verdict

The question “was Jesus a drunkard and a glutton?” has a clear answer. His enemies said so, the Gospels record that they said so, and the Gospel writers recorded it to condemn them.

Muslims reject the charge, as we reject every slander against a prophet of God. The text that preserves it also preserves something its accusers never intended: a Jesus who ate, drank and hungered as men do.

The Qur’an drew the conclusion that the Gospels leave unstated. One who must eat to live is a servant of the One who feeds him.

And only God knows best.

  1. Matthew 11:19 (King James Version). ↩︎
  2. Luke 7:34. ↩︎
  3. Qur’an 19:12–15, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. ↩︎
  4. Deuteronomy 21:18–21 (King James Version). ↩︎
  5. Proverbs 23:20–21 (King James Version). ↩︎
  6. John 2:1–11. ↩︎
  7. Matthew 26:27–29; Mark 14:23–25; Luke 22:17–20. ↩︎
  8. Qur’an 5:90–91. ↩︎
  9. Qur’an 5:75, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. ↩︎
  10. Matthew 4:2. ↩︎
  11. Mark 11:12–13. ↩︎
  12. Luke 24:41–43. ↩︎
  13. Qur’an 5:112–115, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. ↩︎
  14. Qur’an 48:1–2. ↩︎
  15. Qur’an 4:156; 19:27–33. ↩︎

Next in JesusThe Authentic Gospel of Jesus32 min read

Discussion

0 comments

Before you comment

Keep to the argument of the article and cite your sources where you can. Comments that contain links wait for approval, and abusive comments are not published.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.