Critics of the Sunnah often reach for one narration first: the hadith of the fly. The instruction to dip a fallen fly into a drink before removing it strikes them as the clearest proof that the hadith literature contains “a load of nonsense”.
The objection usually arrives with a demand. If the Prophet (P) spoke the truth, the critic says, let modern science produce the cure he described. When Muslim writers point to the microbiology of the fly, the critic dismisses the evidence and declares the hadith refuted.
The critic never makes the case his verdict requires. He would have to show that the narration is weak, or that its ruling is absurd, or that the fly carries nothing that answers to the cure. He shows none of the three.
This article aims to provide context to the hadith of the fly, insha’Allah. We set out the narrations, the legal and medical readings of the classical scholars, the mistakes of the critics, and what the biology of the fly has since found.
The narrations
Abū Hurayrah reports that the Prophet (P) said: “If a house fly falls in the drink of anyone of you, he should dip it (in the drink) and take it out,” for one of its wings carries a disease and the other carries its cure.1
Al-Bukhārī records the narration twice. He places it once in the Book of the Beginning of Creation and once in the Book of Medicine, under the chapter “If a housefly falls in a utensil”.2
Abū Dāwūd records the same narration from Abū Hurayrah: “in one of its wings there is a disease, and in the other is a cure.” Al-Albānī graded it ṣaḥīḥ (sound).3 Abū Dāwūd’s version adds that the fly shields itself with the wing that carries the disease.
A second Companion, Abū Saʿīd al-Khudrī, reports the same teaching in the collection of Ibn Mājah. In his wording the fly puts forward the poison and holds back the cure.4
So the hadith reaches us through two Companions and several independent chains, in the most rigorous collection of the Sunnah. Its authenticity is a question for the science of hadith, and that science answered it centuries ago.
What the hadith instructs
Read the narration slowly. It addresses a person whose drink a fly has already spoiled.
The Prophet (P) gave no instruction to catch flies, to put them in food or to drink what they touch. He spoke to a man in seventh-century Arabia who had a single cup of milk or water and a fly floating in it. Should he pour it away?
The hadith answers that he need not. He may dip the fly, remove it, and keep his drink.
The classical commentators gloss it: “The command denotes counsel (al-amru lil-irshād).” The order guides, and it obliges no one.5
The jurists drew a legal ruling from the hadith that matters more than any laboratory claim. The fly is ritually pure (ṭāhir), and so is any creature without flowing blood. Its fall into a liquid does not make the liquid impure (najis), even when the fly dies in it.6
This was the question of the hadith for the people who first heard it. A Muslim who finds a fly in his drink may still pray, cook and wash with it. Islamic law forbids waste, and the poor of Madinah could not afford to throw away a cup of milk.
Where the critics go wrong
The critics’ case rests on two moves, and neither survives a reading of the sources.
The first move is to mock the question of which wing carries the cure. The critics quote Ibn Ḥajar, who wrote that he found nothing in the narrations to identify the wing. One scholar, Ibn Ḥajar added, claimed to have observed the fly protecting itself with its left wing.
They find the report ridiculous.
Read Ibn Ḥajar again. He reports that the narrations leave the wing unnamed, and he attributes the left-wing claim to an unnamed observer as one opinion among others.7
The hadith names no wing. A discovery that microbes live on both wings leaves it untouched.
The second move concerns the fly’s own immunity. Muslim writers have long reasoned that a creature carrying so many pathogens must carry some protection against them. The critics reply that flies do not succumb to human diseases.
That reply is half true. The fly lives on dung, rotting flesh and waste, among bacteria and fungi that do threaten it. It survives there because it carries a strong immune defence.
What the fly genome showed
In 2014 a team led by Jeffrey Scott of Cornell University published the genome of Musca domestica, the house fly. Its title described the insect as “a global vector of diseases with adaptations to a septic environment”.8
Cornell’s report of the study stated that adult house flies “carry and transmit more than 100 human and animal diseases”, and that the genome revealed “an expanded number of immune response and defense genes” compared with the fruit fly.9
So the fly carries a heavy microbial load, and it carries an unusually large arsenal against microbes. The picture of a passive carrier that suffers nothing from its load is too simple.
Research has continued since. A review published in 2022 by Nurdjannah Jane Niode and colleagues surveyed the antimicrobial potential of the house fly. The authors reported antibacterial activity in extracts from its external surface, its wings, its internal organs and its whole body.10
What the journals have found
The first laboratory evidence is almost a century old. In 1927 the American scientist Richard Shope prepared a saline extract of house flies. It held a bacteriophage active against four species of bacteria, and a second substance, distinct from the phage, that checked the growth of four other species.11
In 1990 scientists publishing at King Abdulaziz University in Jeddah tested the act the hadith commands. Nabih Baeshen and his colleagues collected house flies in Jeddah and Makkah. They let some fall into sterile water and milk, and they dipped others completely, once and three times.
Dipping lowered the contamination. In milk, complete immersion reduced the initial microbial load and slowed later growth, the reverse of what a careless observer would expect from pushing a dirty insect further into the drink. The authors concluded that “all these observations suggest the presence of antimicrobial factors on the house flies.”12 In a later account of the same work they reported mean counts in milk of 165 per millilitre after dipping, against 790.6 after a natural fall.13
The wings themselves have been examined. At the University of Mosul, Al-Taee and Alsammak isolated Streptomyces from the right wing of the house fly and Bacillus mycoides from the left, and both showed antibacterial effects against the species most often found on the fly.14 Streptomyces is the genus that gave medicine streptomycin.
In Saudi Arabia, Galal and colleagues washed the outer surface of house flies and cultured what came off. A strain of Bacillus subtilis from that surface inhibited every other bacterium and fungus they recovered.15
In Indonesia, Claresta and colleagues added one, two or three right wings of the house fly to drinking water contaminated with Escherichia coli. After forty-eight hours of incubation, the plates showed no growth.16
The fly’s own chemistry points the same way. Peng and colleagues identified eleven cecropin genes in Musca domestica; one of the peptides they encode, Cec4, killed the hospital pathogen Acinetobacter baumannii at very low concentrations.17 Qi, Gao and Zhu catalogued some 186 antimicrobial peptides in the house fly, including twenty-one defensins where the fruit fly has one.18 Kawasaki and Andoh found that the body fluid of injured larvae acted strongly against Staphylococcus aureus and Pseudomonas aeruginosa.19
A review in an Islamic science journal drew these threads together in 2021. Its authors traced antimicrobial agents both to the bacteria on the two wings and to the fly’s digestive tract, and they proposed that immersion forces those agents out of the body into the liquid.20
What the evidence shows
The biology now supports each element of the hadith. The fly carries disease. It also carries agents that act against microbes, on its wings and in its body, and the one experiment designed around the Prophetic instruction found that complete immersion lowered the contamination of the drink.
The authority of the hadith rests on its transmission and on the Prophet (P), and it needed no laboratory to stand. The laboratory has since caught up with it.
Ibn al-Qayyim: the legal reading and the medical reading
Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyyah devoted a section of his work on the guidance of the Prophet (P) to this hadith. He divided its meaning in two: a legal matter (amr fiqhī) and a medical matter (amr ṭibbī).21
The legal matter, he wrote, is “a proof of very plain import” that a fly which dies in water or another liquid does not make it impure. This is the position of the great majority of scholars, and he knew of no one among the early generations (al-salaf) who held otherwise.
His reasoning is exact. The Prophet (P) commanded that the fly be immersed, and a fly immersed in food dies, above all when the food is hot.
Had its death made the food impure, the command would have been a command to spoil the food. The Prophet (P) commanded its preservation.
The jurists extended the ruling to every creature without flowing blood (mā lā nafsa lahu sāʾilah): the bee, the wasp, the spider and their like. Ibn al-Qayyim names Ibrāhīm al-Nakhaʿī as the first in Islam known to have used that phrase.
On the medical matter, he observed that the fly carries a venomous strength, shown by the swelling and itching that follow its bite. It defends itself with that weapon when it falls into something that harms it. The Prophet (P) commanded that the venom be met with the cure God placed in the other wing, so that the beneficial matter counters the harmful.
Several physicians, he added, reported that rubbing the site of a wasp or scorpion sting with a fly brings clear relief.22
Ibn al-Qayyim wrote in the fourteenth century, without a microscope. He described a creature that carries harm and the means of countering it, and the genome of the house fly has since shown exactly that pairing.
The verdict
The critics called the hadith of the fly a load of nonsense. They never touched its chains, which run through two Companions into the most rigorous collections of the Sunnah.
They never answered its ruling either. It gives a believer permission to keep a drink a fly has spoiled, and the jurists drew from it a ruling of purity that has governed Muslim practice for fourteen centuries, with no dissent recorded among the early generations.
The fly carries disease, as the hadith says. Modern biology has found that it also carries defences against microbes, on its wings among other places, as Ibn al-Qayyim reasoned seven centuries ago, and the scientists of Jeddah found that immersing the fly lowered the contamination of the drink it fell into.
And only God knows best.
- Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 3320, Book of the Beginning of Creation, narrated by Abū Hurayrah. ↩︎
- Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 5782, Book of Medicine, chapter “If a housefly falls in a utensil”. ↩︎
- Sunan Abī Dāwūd 3844, Book of Foods; graded ṣaḥīḥ by al-Albānī. ↩︎
- Sunan Ibn Mājah 3504, Book of Medicine, narrated by Abū Saʿīd al-Khudrī. ↩︎
- Al-Qasṭallānī, Irshād al-Sārī, commentary on the Book of Medicine. ↩︎
- Cf. al-Baghawī, Sharḥ al-Sunnah, and al-Qasṭallānī, Irshād al-Sārī, on the purity of the fly. ↩︎
- Ibn Ḥajar al-ʿAsqalānī, Fatḥ al-Bārī, commentary on the Book of Medicine. ↩︎
- Jeffrey G. Scott et al., “Genome of the House Fly, Musca domestica L., a Global Vector of Diseases with Adaptations to a Septic Environment”, Genome Biology 15 (2014): 466. ↩︎
- Cornell Chronicle, “House Fly Genome Reveals Expanded Immune System”, 14 October 2014. ↩︎
- Nurdjannah Jane Niode et al., “A Review of the Antimicrobial Potential of Musca domestica as a Natural Approach with Promising Prospects to Countermeasure Antibiotic Resistance” (Hindawi, 2022), doi:10.1155/2022/9346791. ↩︎
- Richard E. Shope, “Bacteriophage Isolated from the Common House Fly (Musca domestica)”, Journal of Experimental Medicine 45, no. 6 (1927): 1037–1044, doi:10.1084/jem.45.6.1037. ↩︎
- N. Baashan (Baeshen) et al., “Effect of Natural Falling and Dipping of House Fly (Musca domestica) on the Microbial Contamination of Water and Milk”, Journal of King Abdulaziz University: Science 2, no. 1 (1990): 45–52. ↩︎
- Nabih Abdulrahman Baeshen et al., “The Effect of Natural Falling and Dipping of House Fly (Musca domestica) on the Microbial Contamination of Water and Milk”, Journal of Food: Microbiology, Safety and Hygiene S3 (2022): 001, doi:10.35248/2476-2059-22.S3.001. ↩︎
- K. M. Al-Taee and E. Gh. Alsammak, “Isolation and Identification of Bacterial Species from House Fly Musca domestica Wings”, Rafidain Journal of Science 22, no. 6 (2011): 11–21, doi:10.33899/rjs.2011.6514. ↩︎
- F. H. Galal, T. El Shammari and A. M. Seufi, “Isolation, Characterization and Antagonistic Activity of the External Microflora of the House Fly, Musca domestica“, Journal of Pure and Applied Microbiology 13, no. 3 (2019): 1619–1628, doi:10.22207/JPAM.13.3.35. ↩︎
- Ivena Claresta et al., “The Right-Wing of Fly (Musca domestica) as a Neutralization of Drinks Contaminated by Microbe”, Journal of Nutritional Science and Vitaminology 66, suppl. (2020): S283–S285, doi:10.3177/jnsv.66.S283. ↩︎
- J. Peng et al., “Antimicrobial Functional Divergence of the Cecropin Antibacterial Peptide Gene Family in Musca domestica“, Parasites and Vectors 12 (2019): 537, doi:10.1186/s13071-019-3793-0. ↩︎
- S. Qi, B. Gao and S. Zhu, “Molecular Diversity and Evolution of Antimicrobial Peptides in Musca domestica“, Diversity 13, no. 3 (2021): 107, doi:10.3390/d13030107. ↩︎
- K. Kawasaki and M. Andoh, “Properties of Induced Antimicrobial Activity in Musca domestica Larvae”, Drug Discoveries and Therapeutics 11, no. 3 (2017): 156–160, doi:10.5582/ddt.2017.01027. ↩︎
- Muhammad Asril et al., “Tracking the Source of Antimicrobial Production from House Fly (Musca domestica): Right-Wing of Fly or Gut System? A Mini-Review”, Elkawnie: Journal of Islamic Science and Technology 7, no. 2 (2021): 225–238, doi:10.22373/ekw.v7i2.9495. ↩︎
- Ibn Qayyim al-Jawziyyah, Zād al-Maʿād fī Hady Khayr al-ʿIbād, vol. 4, pp. 101–102, “faṣl fī hadyihi fī iṣlāḥ al-ṭaʿām alladhī yaqaʿu fīhi al-dhubāb”. ↩︎
- Ibid., vol. 4, p. 102. ↩︎




Leave a Reply