The Qur’an Alone? Five Fallacies in the Case Against the Sunnah

Missionaries and some modern writers urge Muslims to set the hadith aside and keep the Qur’an. The Qur’an itself refuses the offer, and the history of the hadith refutes the claim that it was a late invention.

Written by

Published

Updated

Reading time

7 min read

This article grew out of a thread started on our forum by A. Rafee, who shared an essay titled “The Fallacies of Anti-Hadith Arguments” for discussion.1 We set out the case in our own words and bring the evidence up to date.

Christian missionaries have a favourite move when a hadith embarrasses them. They tell the Muslim that the hadith collections are late, unreliable and man-made, and that a sincere Muslim should rely on the Qur’an alone.

The offer sounds generous. It asks the Muslim to keep his scripture and discard only its commentary.

The same argument appears in the work of orientalists who held that the bulk of the hadith was fabricated in the second and third centuries of Islam. It reaches Muslim readers through translation, often without the evidence that answers it.

This article aims to provide context to that argument, insha’Allah. Its central errors were identified decades ago. We take five of them in turn, and test each against the Qur’an and the historical record.

First fallacy: that the Qur’an does not need an explainer

The argument assumes that the Qur’an was revealed as a text to be read without a teacher. The Qur’an says otherwise about itself.

“And We have sent down to you ˹O Prophet˺ the Reminder so that you may explain to people what has been revealed for them, and perhaps they will reflect.”2 The verse gives the Prophet (P) a task distinct from recitation: explanation.

Another verse lists his functions in full. God sent among the believers a messenger “reciting to them His revelations, purifying them, and teaching them the Book and wisdom”.3

Recitation is only the first of these four functions. Purification, the teaching of the Book and the teaching of wisdom remain. A Muslim who keeps the Qur’an and discards the Prophet’s teaching has kept one task out of four.

Second fallacy: that obedience to the Prophet ended with the revelation

The Qur’an commands obedience to the Messenger alongside obedience to God, and it does so many times. “Whoever obeys the Messenger has truly obeyed Allah.”4

It makes the Prophet’s decisions binding. “Whatever the Messenger gives you, take it.

And whatever he forbids you from, leave it.”5 It denies faith to anyone who refuses his judgment: they will not truly believe “until they accept you ˹O Prophet˺ as the judge in their disputes”.6

It sets him before the believers as a model: “Indeed, in the Messenger of Allah you have an excellent example for whoever has hope in Allah and the Last Day.”7

Someone must preserve that example for those who come after his death, or the command becomes impossible to obey. The hadith literature is that preservation. A Muslim of the fifteenth Islamic century obeys the Prophet (P) through the record of what he said and did.

Third fallacy: that the Qur’an alone gives the practice of Islam

The Qur’an commands prayer at fixed times.8 It names the dawn prayer, the middle prayer and the prayer at night.9 It describes standing, bowing and prostration.

It does not say how many units each prayer has, or what to recite in each posture, or how the prayer begins and ends. The Prophet (P) taught all of it by example: “Pray as you have seen me praying.”10

The same holds for almsgiving. The Qur’an commands zakāh repeatedly and names those entitled to receive it.11 The thresholds, rates and categories of wealth come from the Sunnah.

A Muslim who rejects the Sunnah must either stop praying in the form every Muslim has prayed for fourteen centuries or invent a form of his own. Either way he has left the practice the Qur’an commanded.

Fourth fallacy: that hadith were first written two centuries later

The orientalist case leaned on a picture of an oral tradition that floated for two hundred years before anyone wrote it down. The early sources show writing from the Prophet’s own lifetime.

ʿAbd Allāh ibn ʿAmr ibn al-ʿĀṣ reports that he used to write everything he heard from the Prophet (P). Some of the Quraysh told him to stop, because the Prophet (P) was a man who spoke in anger and in calm. The Prophet (P) pointed to his mouth and said: “Write, by Him in Whose hand my soul lies, only right comes out from it.”12

Abū Hurayrah, the most prolific narrator among the Companions, acknowledged the difference. “There is none among the companions of the Prophet who has narrated more Hadiths than I,” he said, “except ʿAbdullah bin ʿAmr … who used to write them and I never did the same.”13

The critics cite a narration in which the Prophet (P) said, “Do not write anything from me except the Qur’an.”14 The classical scholars reconciled the two reports.

The prohibition belonged to the early period, when the Qur’an was still being revealed and the danger of mixing the two texts was greatest. The permission came later, and the practice of the Companions followed it.

The ṣaḥīfah of ʿAbd Allāh ibn ʿAmr, the written collection of Hammām ibn Munabbih from Abū Hurayrah and the official correspondence of the Prophet (P) all show the same thing. Writing was part of the transmission from the start.

Fifth fallacy: that a chain of men cannot carry the truth

The deepest assumption of the anti-hadith case is that human transmission cannot be trusted. The critic who holds it should consider how he received the Qur’an.

The Qur’an reached every Muslim alive today through the same community of transmitters. Its text was memorised, recited and written by the Companions, collected under Abū Bakr and standardised under ʿUthmān. A man who trusts that chain for the Qur’an cannot reject the same men, the same generation and the same methods when they report the words of the Prophet (P).

The scholars of hadith tested every report. They built a science of criticism unmatched in the ancient world.

Each narrator in a chain was examined for his memory, his honesty and his contact with the man he claimed to quote. Reports were graded sound, good, weak or fabricated, and whole books were written to expose forgeries.

The existence of fabricated hadith proves the existence of the critics who caught them. A community that kept no standard would have kept no lists of forgeries.

Revelation outside the recited text

The Qur’an itself shows that the Prophet (P) received guidance from God that the Qur’an does not record. The clearest case is the direction of prayer.

For a period in Madinah the Muslims prayed facing Jerusalem. No verse of the Qur’an commands that direction. When the change to the Kaʿbah came, the Qur’an said of the earlier direction: “We only made the direction of prayer you used to face to distinguish those who would follow the Messenger from those who would turn back.”15

God claims the earlier qiblah as His own appointment, made through the Messenger, with no verse to announce it. A Muslim who accepts only what the Qur’an states must explain how the Qur’an endorses a command it never stated.

A second case appears in Sūrat al-Taḥrīm. The Prophet (P) confided a matter to one of his wives, and she disclosed it.

When he told her what she had done, she asked who had informed him. “The All-Knowing, All-Aware informed me,” he said.16

The Qur’an records the fact of that information and leaves its content unrecorded. It shows a Prophet who received knowledge from God beyond the words of the recited Book, and it expects the believers to accept that knowledge as divine.

The Sunnah is the record of that knowledge in practice. Its scholars preserved it with the same care the Companions gave to the Qur’an.

Why the missionary makes the offer

The missionary who urges a Muslim to abandon the hadith rarely does so out of concern for the purity of the Qur’an. He knows that the Qur’an without the Prophet’s explanation becomes a text he can read as he likes.

He then returns, in the next debate, to quote a weak hadith as proof against Islam. The same writers who call the hadith worthless will cite it at length when it suits a polemic.

The goal is a reduced Islam: a set of general principles, emptied of the practice that gives them shape, which an outsider may then fill as he pleases.

The verdict

The Qur’an appoints the Prophet (P) to explain it, commands obedience to him, makes his judgment binding and holds him up as the model for every believer. It leaves the form of the prayer and the measures of the alms to his teaching.

His Companions wrote down his words in his lifetime, with his permission. The community that carried the Qur’an carried the Sunnah, and its scholars built a science to separate the sound report from the forged one.

The offer of “the Qur’an alone” asks the Muslim to keep the Book and dismiss the teacher the Book appointed. The Qur’an refuses that offer on its own authority.

And only God knows best.

  1. Shah Shahidullah Faridi, “The Fallacies of Anti-Hadith Arguments”, in Hadith and Sunnah: Ideals and Realities, ed. P. K. Koya (Islamic Book Trust, 1996; 2nd rev. ed., 2000). ↩︎
  2. Qur’an 16:44, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. ↩︎
  3. Qur’an 3:164, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran; cf. 2:151; 62:2. ↩︎
  4. Qur’an 4:80, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. ↩︎
  5. Qur’an 59:7, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. ↩︎
  6. Qur’an 4:65, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. ↩︎
  7. Qur’an 33:21, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. ↩︎
  8. Qur’an 4:103. ↩︎
  9. Qur’an 2:238; 11:114; 17:78. ↩︎
  10. Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 631, Book of the Call to Prayer. ↩︎
  11. Qur’an 9:60. ↩︎
  12. Sunan Abī Dāwūd 3646, Book of Knowledge; graded ṣaḥīḥ by al-Albānī. ↩︎
  13. Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 113, Book of Knowledge. ↩︎
  14. Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 3004, Book of Zuhd and Softening of Hearts. ↩︎
  15. Qur’an 2:143, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. ↩︎
  16. Qur’an 66:3, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. ↩︎

Next in HadithDid al-Zuṭṭ Ride Muhammad? A Critical Philological Reassessment of a Modern Anti-Islam Polemic16 min read

Discussion

0 comments

Before you comment

Keep to the argument of the article and cite your sources where you can. Comments that contain links wait for approval, and abusive comments are not published.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.