Sage and Prophet on Trial: A Buddhist Indictment of Muhammad (P) Re-examined

A Buddhist polemicist set the Buddha’s counsel on criticism against a disputed report about the Prophet (P). The report fails, and the contrast fails with it.

Published

Updated

Reading time

7 min read

The allegation arrived dressed as comparative spirituality. A Buddhist polemic set out “to show the glaring contrast between authentic sages and the spiritual paths they brought” and the Prophet Muhammad (P).

It called him a “self-professed prophet slash con-artist”. His religion, in its words, was a “destructive, head-shrinking fascist cult”.

The case rested on two exhibits. The first was a discourse in which the Buddha counsels his monks on how to receive criticism. The second was the story of Asma’ bint Marwan, a poetess of Madinah said to have been killed at the Prophet’s order for her verses against him.

From the pairing it drew a verdict. One man was a sage; the other could not bear dissent.

This article aims to provide context to that comparison, insha’Allah. We answer it on its own ground: the reliability of the report, the documented conduct of the Prophet (P) toward his critics, and the method by which a fair inquirer weighs one tradition against another.

The frame of the inquiry

The opening line settled the case before a single source appeared. The Buddha sits in the class of “authentic sages” and the Prophet (P) in the class of “con-artists”.

Everything after that line was arranged to confirm it.

We decline the arrangement. A comparison between two religious founders is scholarship when both men are measured by the same standard.

The polemic gave one founder the most generous reading of his scripture. It gave the other the most hostile reading of a disputed report. Call it advocacy in the vocabulary of comparison.

The insults deserve one observation. A writer who demands courtesy for one sage while denying it to the Prophet (P) tells the reader more about the method than about either man.

The Buddhist exhibit

The first exhibit was offered as a Buddhist “hadith”. It comes from the opening of the Brahmajāla Sutta, the first discourse of the Dīgha Nikāya.1

A wandering ascetic named Suppiya speaks against the Buddha, his teaching and his community, while his own pupil Brahmadatta praises them. The Buddha later tells his monks that if others speak in dispraise of him, they should feel neither anger nor resentment, and should calmly separate what is false from what is true.

We have no quarrel with the counsel. Muslims will recognise its spirit at once.

Our objection concerns the use made of it. The polemic offered it as proof that Buddhism alone “encourages freedom of thoughts and inquiries”, and paired it with the Kālāma Sutta, in which the Buddha tells the people of Kesaputta to test a teaching before accepting it.2

The Qur’an makes the same demand of its own hearers, repeatedly. It rebukes those who follow their forefathers without reflection.

It asks, again and again, “will you not reason?” (a-fa-lā taʿqilūn). It sends its audience to the heavens, the earth and their own selves for evidence.3

A scripture that commands its listeners to reason cannot fairly be described as one that “discouraged anyone from thinking for themselves”. The contrast had already failed before the second exhibit arrived.

The report of Asma’ bint Marwan

The second exhibit carries the whole weight of the case. It deserves the closest examination.

The story appears in the early biographical literature: in the sīrah (prophetic biography) of Ibn Isḥāq, in the Maghāzī (campaign histories) of al-Wāqidī, and in the Ṭabaqāt of Ibn Saʿd.4

In outline, a woman of the Banū Umayyah ibn Zayd composed verses inciting her people against the Muslims after Badr. A blind man of her own clan, ʿUmayr ibn ʿAdī, is said to have killed her by night.

A report is only as strong as its chain of transmission (isnād). Here the chain breaks.

The narration traced back to Ibn ʿAbbās passes through one Muḥammad ibn al-Ḥajjāj al-Lakhmī. The early critics of narrators accused him of forging it, and Ibn ʿAdī recorded the report under his name in a collection devoted to weak transmitters.5

Ibn al-Jawzī listed the report among defective narrations. In the twentieth century al-Albānī judged it fabricated, and he noted that the version in Ibn Saʿd rests on al-Wāqidī, a historian whom the early hadith critics refused to accept as a transmitter of law.6

The content fares no better than the chain. Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī records that when a woman was found killed during one of the campaigns, “Allah’s Messenger (ﷺ) forbade the killing of women and children.”7

So the story has the Prophet (P) commissioning the night killing of a nursing mother, against a prohibition that the most rigorous hadith collection attributes to him. Classical method resolves that conflict in favour of the sound report.

The polemic reversed the order, because the weak report served its purpose.

Some Muslim writers have accepted the story and defended it as a wartime measure against incitement in a city with no police and no courts. That defence concedes more than the evidence requires.

The honest position is the plainer one. The story fails the standard required to attribute an act to the Prophet (P), and it should not be used to describe him.

What the sound sources establish

The polemic asked how the Prophet (P) received hostility. The sound sources answer her directly.

After the reverse at Uḥud, when some of his companions had disobeyed his orders and fled the field, the Qur’an addressed him: “It is out of Allah’s mercy that you ˹O Prophet˺ have been lenient with them.”8

The same verse tells him that harshness would have scattered them. It commands him to pardon them, to seek forgiveness for them and to consult them in affairs.

The biographical literature preserves an episode that tests this mercy under exactly the provocation the polemic described. Zayd ibn Saʿnah, a rabbi of Madinah, had sold the Prophet (P) dates on credit.

Some days before the debt fell due, Zayd seized the Prophet (P) by his garment in public and demanded payment in insulting terms. ʿUmar ibn al-Khaṭṭāb rose in anger and threatened him.

The Prophet (P) restrained ʿUmar. He told him that both parties deserved better counsel from him, and ordered him to pay the debt in full with twenty ṣāʿ (a measure of volume) of dates added, as compensation for the fright ʿUmar had caused.

Zayd then explained that he had been testing the signs of prophethood he knew from his own scripture. He accepted Islam on the spot.9

The episode answers every question the polemic raised. A member of another faith insulted the Prophet (P) openly, in public, and laid hands on him. The Prophet (P) stopped the companion who wished to punish the man, and then paid the man more than he was owed.

The case of ʿAbd Allāh ibn Ubayy shows the same restraint toward an enemy inside the Muslim camp. The leader of the hypocrites of Madinah insulted the Prophet (P) during a campaign, declaring that “the more honourable” would expel “the meaner” from the city on their return.10

ʿUmar asked leave to kill him. The Prophet (P) refused, saying that he would not have people say that Muhammad kills his companions.11 Ibn Ubayy lived out his life in Madinah, and when he died the Prophet (P) prayed over him.

The conquest of Makkah supplies the larger proof. The city that had expelled him, killed his companions and fought him for eight years lay open before him, and he granted it a general amnesty.

The poet who came back

One more episode answers the charge that the Prophet (P) silenced poets. Kaʿb ibn Zuhayr had composed verses against him and fled when Makkah fell.

He came to Madinah in disguise, sat before the Prophet (P) and asked whether he would accept Kaʿb if Kaʿb came repentant. The Prophet (P) said that he would. Kaʿb then named himself and recited the ode that opens Bānat Suʿād.

The early sources report that the Prophet (P) gave him his own mantle.12 The poem survives, and Muslims have recited it for fourteen centuries.

One standard for both traditions

The method can be tested on Buddhism itself. Suppose a critic searched the later chronicles of a Buddhist kingdom for a disputed report of violence done in the Buddha’s name.

Suppose the critic then ignored its chain, ignored the canonical teaching that contradicts it, and presented it as the “ultimate example” of the Buddha’s character. Buddhists would reject the exercise, and they would be right to.

We ask for the same justice and nothing more. We have offered no argument here against the Buddha, and we decline to offer one, because the dignity of one tradition is never established by degrading another.

The question raised concerns the Prophet (P) alone. It is answered from the sources about him.

The verdict

The polemic asked why Muslims cannot see that “no way Muhammad can be considered a decent human being”. Muslims read the sources.

Her central exhibit is a report that classical and modern critics rejected. Its chain runs through an accused forger, and its content contradicts a sound prohibition in Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī.

Against it stand the Qur’an’s own account of the Prophet’s leniency, the episode of Zayd ibn Saʿnah and the amnesty at Makkah.

A sage is measured by what can be shown of him. Measured that way, the promised “glaring contrast” disappears. What remains is a polemic that reached its verdict first and went looking for evidence afterwards.

And only God knows best.

  1. Brahmajāla Sutta, Dīgha Nikāya 1, §§1.1–1.6. ↩︎
  2. Kesamutti (Kālāma) Sutta, Aṅguttara Nikāya 3.65. ↩︎
  3. Cf. Qur’an 2:170, 2:44, 3:190–191 and 51:20–21. ↩︎
  4. Ibn Isḥāq, The Life of Muhammad, trans. A. Guillaume (Oxford University Press, 1955), pp. 675–676; al-Wāqidī, The Life of Muhammad: al-Wāqidī’s Kitāb al-Maghāzī, ed. Rizwi Faizer (Routledge, 2011), p. 86; Ibn Saʿd, al-Ṭabaqāt al-Kubrā, vol. 2, pp. 30–31. ↩︎
  5. Ibn ʿAdī, al-Kāmil fī Ḍuʿafāʾ al-Rijāl, vol. 7, p. 326, entry on Muḥammad ibn al-Ḥajjāj al-Lakhmī. ↩︎
  6. Ibn al-Jawzī, al-ʿIlal al-Mutanāhiyah, vol. 1, p. 175, no. 279, quoting Ibn ʿAdī: “hādhā mimmā yuttaham Muḥammad ibn al-Ḥajjāj bi-waḍʿihi” (this is among what Muḥammad ibn al-Ḥajjāj is accused of fabricating); Muḥammad Nāṣir al-Dīn al-Albānī, Silsilat al-Aḥādīth al-Ḍaʿīfah wa al-Mawḍūʿah, no. 6013. ↩︎
  7. Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 3015, Book of Jihād, chapter “Killing the women in the war”. ↩︎
  8. Qur’an 3:159, trans. Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. ↩︎
  9. al-Ḥākim, al-Mustadrak ʿalā al-Ṣaḥīḥayn, Book of the Companions, no. 6547; also recorded by Ibn Ḥibbān and al-Ṭabarānī. ↩︎
  10. Qur’an 63:8. ↩︎
  11. Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī 4905, Book of Tafsīr, commentary on Sūrat al-Munāfiqūn. ↩︎
  12. Ibn Isḥāq, The Life of Muhammad, trans. A. Guillaume, on the coming of Kaʿb ibn Zuhayr; the gift of the mantle is reported in later sources. ↩︎

Next in MuhammadAnother Rational Approach To The Prophethood of Muhammad16 min read

Discussion

0 comments

Before you comment

Keep to the argument of the article and cite your sources where you can. Comments that contain links wait for approval, and abusive comments are not published.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.