What is the Sig­nif­i­cance of the Cres­cent Moon in Islam ?

Mohd Elfie Nieshaem Juferi

Apart from the claim that Allah” is the name of the moon god, the Chris­t­ian mis­sion­ar­ies also tend assert this claim by ques­tion­ing why the cres­cent moon in Islam is used as a sym­bol to rep­re­sent the reli­gion, or why is the cres­cent moon or full moon used in Islam to mark a new month in the Islam­ic lunar calendar. 

They engage into the log­i­cal fal­la­cy of equiv­o­ca­tion to jus­ti­fy their alle­ga­tion ; since Mus­lims use the cres­cent sym­bol to rep­re­sent Islam, it there­fore also fol­lows that Mus­lims wor­ship some kind of moon god” and Islam is the reli­gion of the moon god. 

How­ev­er, this is no more truer than claim­ing that since Judaism adopts the Star of David sym­bol, it fol­lows that the Jews con­sid­ers it as an object for wor­ship, or that Chris­tians wor­ship the Cru­ci­fix since it is used as its sym­bol.

Does The Cres­cent Sym­bol Rep­re­sent A Deity ?

To begin, let us define the mean­ing of the Ara­bic word Allah”, as used by Mus­lims to refer to God. Lane’s Lex­i­con defines the mean­ing of the word Allah” as refer­ring to the only true god”:

What is the Significance of the Crescent Moon in Islam? 1Edward William Lane, An Ara­bic-Eng­lish Lex­i­con (Lon­don : Willams & Nor­gate, 1863), under the entry Allah” (Ar.)

How­ev­er, let us now look at a dif­fer­ent approach to the issue, i.e. the pur­pose of the moon in Islam, and a com­par­i­son of this with the oth­er Abra­ham­ic reli­gions, name­ly Judaism and Christianity. 

This paper will attempt to explain the sig­nif­i­cance of the cres­cent moon in Islam and repu­di­ate the idea that Islam con­dones moon wor­ship, insha’Allah.

Islam and the Cres­cent Moon

Islam nev­er teach­es nor does it expound moon wor­ship. It, in fact, repu­di­ates it, as the fol­low­ing verse confirms :

Among His Signs are the Night and the Day and the Sun and Moon. Pros­trate (adore) not to the Sun and the Moon but pros­trate to God, Who cre­at­ed them, if it is Him ye wish to serve.” (Qur’an, 41 : 37)

So what is the func­tion of the moon in Islam ? The only func­tion it plays in Islam is that it deter­mines the Islam­ic lunar cal­en­dar. The Qur’an con­firms this when it speaks of the moon being sub­ject to God’s Law. 

We read the fol­low­ing verse :

They ask you, [O Muham­mad], about the new moons. Say, They are mea­sure­ments of time for the peo­ple and for Hajj.” And it is not right­eous­ness to enter hous­es from the back, but right­eous­ness is [in] one who fears Allah. And enter hous­es from their doors. And fear Allah that you may suc­ceed.” (Qur’an, 2:189)

We are also informed of the following :

Seest thou not that God merges Night into Day and He merges Day into Night ; that he has sub­ject­ed the sun and the moon (to His Law), each run­ning its course for a term appoint­ed : and that God is well acquaint­ed with all that ye do?” (Qur’an, 31:29)

If Allah” (God) is indeed the moon god” as claimed by mis­guid­ed Chris­tians, why would that very same moon-god” cre­ate the moon for the use of mankind ? 

In short, the claim that Mus­lims wor­ship Allah the moon-god” sim­ply because of the cres­cent sym­bol is noth­ing but a heinous lie which is not based on any con­crete evidence.

Judaism and the Moon

It is inter­est­ing to note that the Jews also adopt the lunar cal­en­dar to mark their holy fes­ti­vals. The Jew­ish reli­gious cal­en­dar, of Baby­lon­ian ori­gin, con­sists of 12 lunar months, amount­ing to about 354 days. Six times in a 19-year cycle a 13th month is added to adjust the cal­en­dar to the solar year. The day is reck­oned from sun­set to sun­set. http://​www​.webear​.com/​r​e​l​i​e​n​g​l​.​h​t​m​#​*​t​op4

The moon also plays an impor­tant role in a sym­bol­ic com­par­i­son with the Jew­ish nation. We repro­duce below an arti­cle writ­ten by Rab­bi Avro­hom Berg­er that states as such.

The Symbolic Comparision of the Jews and the Moon

The arti­cle above would clear­ly refute the non­sense that Islam based its cal­en­dar on the moon because it was a reli­gion of the moon god, for if Islam was real­ly the reli­gion of the moon god, what is the reli­gion of the Jews who used (and still use) the lunar cal­en­dar and con­stant­ly analo­gizes itself to the moon ? 

In fact, a Jew­ish site con­firmed the above by stat­ing :

The Jew­ish Nation has been likened to the moon. Our his­to­ry, cycli­cal in nature, wax­es and wanes like the moon through its cycle hid­den at times, but always reemerg­ing to full blos­som.http://​www​.judaism​.com/​c​a​l​e​n​d​a​r​2000​/​b​a​c​k​g​r​o​u​d​.​htm

Con­demn­ing the Jew­ish reli­gion as moon wor­ship” based on the log­ic” (or rather, the lack of it!) of the Chris­t­ian mis­sion­ar­ies would, how­ev­er, lead to seri­ous impli­ca­tions that could under­mine their own faith, as Jesus(P) was a learned Rab­bi and faith­ful Jew him­self. How­ev­er, they have no qualms con­demn­ing Islam for using the lunar cal­en­dar. Such dou­ble stan­dards are not alien to Chris­t­ian thought, after all the end jus­ti­fies the means, just as Paul did the same.

Chris­tian­i­ty and The Sun

We have seen that both Judaism and Islam, as in the tra­di­tion of Semit­ic cul­ture, use the lunar cal­en­dar to mark their months. The ques­tion now is why Chris­tian­i­ty adopt­ed the solar cal­en­dar, instead of the lunar ? 

As sur­pris­ing as it may seem to the mis­sion­ary, the adop­tion of the sun as the offi­cial cal­en­dar of Chris­tian­i­ty’ occurred as late as 325 C.E. and was due to the pre­vail­ing pagan influ­ences of sun wor­ship. Chris­tians chose to cel­e­brate the birth of Jesus on 25th Decem­ber because this was the date of an already exist­ing fes­ti­val of the Sol Invic­tus was expressed in an anno­ta­tion to a man­u­script of a work by 12th-cen­tu­ry Syr­i­an bish­op Jacob Bar-Sal­i­bi. The scribe who added it wrote : 

It was a cus­tom of the Pagans to cel­e­brate on the same 25 Decem­ber the birth­day of the Sun, at which they kin­dled lights in token of fes­tiv­i­ty. In these solem­ni­ties and rev­el­ries, the Chris­tians also took part. Accord­ing­ly, when the doc­tors of the Church per­ceived that the Chris­tians had a lean­ing to this fes­ti­val, they took coun­sel and resolved that the true Nativ­i­ty should be solem­nised on that day.“Ram­say Mac­Mullen, Chris­tian­i­ty and Pagan­ism in the Fourth to Eighth Cen­turies” (Yale, 1997), p. 155

The cult of the sun-god was the most pop­u­lar creed at the advent of Jesus(P) and was preva­lent in all the coun­tries into which the reli­gion called Chris­tian­i­ty” was lat­er intro­duced in. Pagan gods such as Apol­lo or Diony­sus among the Greeks, Her­cules among the Romans, Mithra among the Per­sians, and Osiris, Isis and Horus in Egypt et. al., are all sun-godsSee Ahmad Zidan, Chris­tian­i­ty : Myth or Mes­sage ?, A.S. Noordeen (Malaysia), 1995.

In the face of the evi­dence, one can­not help but con­clude that the adop­tion of the solar cal­en­dar is cer­tain­ly due to the strong Hel­lenis­tic influ­ences of the sun-god cult dur­ing its adoption.

Con­clu­sions

It is clear that the cre­ation of a cal­en­dar is for the pur­pose of keep­ing time in per­spec­tive. Time is mea­sured in rel­a­tive terms, from sun­rise to sun­set ; from the time the sun casts the short­est shad­ow to the same time the next day ; from one har­vest time to another. 

In ancient times, the phas­es of the moon were an easy means of mea­sur­ing the pas­sage of time. The first cal­en­dars were lunar cal­en­dars. Ancient civ­i­liza­tions such as the Assyr­i­ans, Baby­lo­ni­ans, Egyp­tians and the Chi­nese used the lunar calendar. 

Con­se­quent­ly, the Semit­ic cul­ture also adopt­ed this cal­en­dar which includes Judaism and Islam, with the excep­tion of Chris­tian­i­ty using the solar cal­en­dar due to pagan Hel­lenis­tic influ­ences from the Gre­co-Roman cul­ture. Clear­ly, the pur­pose of the cres­cent moon in Islam is noth­ing more than to keep track of dates and months as Islam adopts and utilis­es the lunar cal­en­dar. In light of this fact, Islam, there­fore, uses the cres­cent sym­bol to rep­re­sent the reli­gion graph­i­cal­ly. There is no log­i­cal rea­son to asso­ciate the lunar cal­en­dar of Islam with moon wor­ship.

And cer­tain­ly, only God knows best ! What is the Significance of the Crescent Moon in Islam? 2

[cite]

TAGS